To be honest @JenBainbridge, we have only had them off lead once together a few weeks ago and Red kept jumping on Sky. However, we have walked them on lead a few times together and the last time was really good. Red had changed a lot the last few weeks so she might. On the beach though Sky loves to swim and I feel nervous about Red following. It's going to be a whole new experience. Dogs are spending much more time together indoors - we have been focusing on that really. Both in their beds here as I type .