Hi Hi Pippa and all on the forum! We are following the Happy Puppy crate training instructions with our almost 10 week black lab. We are at stage 2 and she happily chews her stuffed kong for around 10-15 minutes with us sitting next to her (while we are reading emails on our phone). She doesn’t whine much after the kitchen kong is empty, but sits up looking at us with the occasional whine. (Not loud at all) We pop extra kibble in occasionally to stretch out the time and only when she is quiet. She lasts up to 20mins (just over 20 minutes actually) we only let her out when quiet. And give her lots of praise and cuddles and more treats. We know that we need to wait until she is laying down in a relaxed state before moving on to stage 3 (with us away from crate in the same room) but should we be aiming to extend her time in the crate at the current stage (2)? Or do we keep our sessions at 20 minutes and just wait until she relaxes as opposed to sitting up looking at us? Thanks for any one who may reply!!